Supreme Court of Vermont May 15, 1894 (Merchants' National Bank v. Taylor)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1894
THOMPSON, J.
I. The defendant, by false and fraudulent representations in respect to his farm being free and clear from all incumbrances, induced the plaintifF to surrender to him about $900 worth of ‘ ‘trade paper” upon which he was liable to the plaintiff, and which was then overdue, and to take in lieu thereof his note for nine hundred dollars secured by a mortgage on the farm. Either the surrender of the “trade paper,” or the forbearance of the plaintiff by virtue of this arrangement, was a sufficient consideration, to bind the defendant by his representations, when thus acted upon by the plaintiff. Ballard v. Burton, 64 Vt. 387. The plaintiff did not rescind this contract on account of the fraud, but elected to affirm it. It thereby had two causes of action against the defendant, the one on the contract evidenced by the note, and the other in tort for the false and fraudulent representations. Both actions must proceed upon the part of the plaintiff, on the theory of an affirmance of the contract. Although differing in lorm, one would not allege what the other would deny. But while consistent, they are not identical; the one proceeds upon the theory of a tort, and the other upon contract. A party may prosecute as many remedies as he legally has, if they are consistent and concurrent, and a recovery in one does not constitute a bar to the other. Johnson v. Worden, 47 Vt. 457; Darling v. Woodward, 54 Vt. 101; Bean v. Fox, 1 Bradwell 177; Goldberg v. Dougherty, 39 N. Y. Super. Ct. 189; Bowen, Exr. v. Mandeville, 95 N. Y. 237.
*578It is urged that this action cannot be maintained by reason of the defendant’s discharge in insolvency, plaintiff having proved the note against the insolvent estate, and received a dividend thereon in the insolvency proceedings. But any legitimate proceeding to collect the note, as we have already seen, does not bar plaintiff’s right to its action for the tort.
R. L., s.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit