Supreme Court of the United States May 26, 1894, 883 (Interstate Commerce Commission v. Brimson)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-05-1894

Mr. Justice Brewer,

with whom concurred

The Chief Justice and Mr. Justice Jackson, dissenting. •

I dissent from the opinion and judgment of the court in this case. I notice, as a .preliminary matter, a practice which I think is not to be commended and ought not to be pursued. The application to punish the three appellees was denied by the Circuit Court. The reason given for the decision was the unconstitutionality of that portion of the interstate commerce act which requires a court to treat and punish as a contempt of its authority the refusal of a witness before the commission to answer questions. In the opinion this court.considers that reason, holds it unsound, and remands the case for further proceedings. On such further proceedings the Circuit Court may, without disobedience of the mandate, again deny the application, for the further reason that the questions propounded by the commission to the witnesses are deemed irrelevant or incompetent; and on a second appeal it may be that this court will also be of the same opinion; and then this curi

*4

ous result will appear: Of two successive judgments in the same case, each denying the same application, this court sustains one and reverses the other. I had supposed the rule was settled that the inquiry in this court was simply whether that which was adjudged by. the trial court was erroneous, and not whether the reasons given therefor were good or bad, and that a correct judgment was always sustained, even if the reasons given therefor were erroneous. But this is a minor matter, and I only notice it to express my dissent frpm the practice.

I pass, therefore, to the important question considered by the court in its opinion. With the bulk of that opinion I have no disposition to-quarrel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.