New York Court of Appeals April 9, 1895 (People v. . Turner)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1895

Gray, J.

The appellant in this case is the same person, whose appeal was recently under review by us. (117 N. Y. 227.) The decision there made must be regarded as operative in the present appeal. In the former case the action was' to recover penalties for cutting trees upon certain lands in Franklin county, in this state; while in this case the action is one of replevin to recover logs taken by the defendant from other lands in that county. The facts, affecting the defendant’s position towards the lands, differ in the two cases, in this; that in the earlier case the defendant was not in possession and showed no title to the lands and was, therefore, a trespasser ; while in the present case he claims to have acquired the title and to have been in possession. Although we might safely rest the determination of this appeal upon the decision rendered in the previous case, where the question was treated as though the defendant had a right, as an owner of the property, to rebut the plaintiff’s proof of title, I will, nevertheless, state, briefly, the reasons for affirming this judgment.

The facts respecting the acquisition of title by the defendant are these, viz.: that the defendant received in 1886 a deed from one Riley, who, in the same year, had acquired an interest in the lands by a conveyance from six of the eight children of one Norton. Norton had acquired the lands in 1872 from the Barnards, who appear to have held the same by tax title. Norton died in 1882 and, subsequently to his death, the conveyance to Riley was made by six of his children, which I mentioned. The plaintiff’s title to the lands was acquired through a conveyance by the comptroller to the state, October 12th, 1877. He had purchased the same at tax sales, made for the unpaid taxes of the years 1866 to 1870, inclusive. His deed was made June 9th, 1881, and was recorded June 8th,

*456

1882. The two years allowed for redemption had expired October 12th, 1879.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.