New York Supreme Court March 30, 1895 (Robinson v. Grannis)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-03-1895
WRIGHT, J.
The bargain provided that the stone should be paid for at §6.50 per cord, “measured in the wall.” The plaintiff claims that since 128 cubic feet of stone make only 99 cubic feet when laid into a wall of masonry, the wall should be measured at the rate of 99 cubic feet per cord. The defendant claims that the standard measurement of 128 cubic feet per cord should be applied to the wall. A local custom of Oswego City, where the contract was made, regulates the measurement according to the plaintiff’s contention; but since the defendant, a stranger, had no knowledge of it, that custom cannot be considered. Corn Exch. Bank v. Nassau Bank, 91 N. Y. 74. All the circumstances of the bargain, however, are to be considered in determining in what sense the term “cord” was used and understood in the contract. Kennedy v. Railroad Co., 67 Barb. 169. “It is a rule of law, as well as of ethics, that where the language of a promisor may be understood in more senses than one, it is to be interpreted in the sense in which he had reason to suppose it was understood by the promisee.” Hoffman v. Insurance Co., 32 N. Y. 405. Also, in construing the words of a covenant, “if the intention of the parties be doubtful, that construction is to be adopted which is most beneficial to the covenantee.” Marvin v. Stone, 2 Cow. 806. At the bargain, the plaintiff offered the stone at §6 per cord. Grannis said he would do better than that, and pay what he Avas paying others, §6.50 per cord, measured in the Avail. The plaintiff and Grannis were experienced dealers in stone and practical masonry, and knew that 128 cubic feet of rough stone make only 99 cubic feet of masonry.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit