New York Supreme Court October 18, 1895 (White v. Koster)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-10-1895
PER CURIAM.
The order appealed from denied plaintiff’s motion to make certain allegations of the answer more definite and certain, by stating the character of the license which defendants held from the mayor to maintain a place of amusement at Twenty-Third street. The complaint alleged a contract with the plaintiff’s assignor, Marie Lloyd, by which she agreed to take part in certain performances, to be given by the defendants, for a period of nine weeks, and that she was induced to make such contract by the representations of the defendants that they had a variety theater on Twenty-Third street, near Sixth avenue, in the city of New York, where they were authorized to conduct a theatrical business; but that the defendants did not have, at the time of the making of the contract, or during the period provided for its continuance, a theatrical license allowing them to conduct a theater of any kind at such place. The answer alleges possession of a place on Twenty-Third street by the defendants, where public performances of such character as that contemplated in the contract could lawfully be given, and that they held a license from the mayor to maintain such place for such public performances. The answer, therefore, definitely and certainly *372put in issue the allegations of the complaint referred to, and more than that the plaintiff is not entitled to have on a motion of this character. What he seeks to obtain is the evidence upon which the defendants rely to support their denials of plaintiff’s allegations, and their affirmative allegations that they held a license from the mayor authorizing them to give such performances as the contract contemplated. That evidence the special term properly decided they were not entitled to have, under the guise of making the answer more definite and certain. The defendants opened their second defense with the phrase, “Reiterating the denials and repeating the allegations contained in their first defense.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit