Indiana Supreme Court May 1, 1895, No. 17,367 (Eaton v. Union County National Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-1895

Hackney, J.

The appellee, a National banking association organized pursuant to, and engaged in banking under, the laws of the United States, returned to the proper township assessor and to the county auditor duplicate lists of assessment for taxation of its capital stock for the year 1891. The valuation of such stock was made by the township assessor corresponding with that returned by the appellee and before the county assessor and the county board of review the same valuation was maintained without objection or question. Without appeal, but upon the assumption of supposed original jurisdiction, the State Board of Tax Commissioners increased said valuation $20,000, and certified such action to the county auditor, with instructions to increase such valuation in such sum and to add and extend the tax thereon against the appellee. Obeying the direction of the State Board of Tax Commissioners, said additional tax *137was extended on the duplicate against the appellee and the appellant threatened to enforce the same. By its complaint, in this suit, the appellee sought and obtained an injunction against the collection of such added tax.

The only alleged error in the proceedings of the circuit court is in overruling the appellant’s demurrer to said complaint.

It has several times been held that under the act of March 6, 1891 (Acts 1891, p. 199, R. S. 1894, section 8408 et seq.), the State Board of Tax Commissioners possessed no original jurisdiction for the assessment and valuation of property such as that of the appellee, and that the assumption of such jurisdiction was void. Cummings, Treas., v. Stark, 138 Ind. 94; Jones, Treas., v. Rushville, etc., Bank, 138 Ind. 87; First Nat’l Bank, etc., v. Brodhecker, Treas., 137 Ind. 693; Conzman, Treas., v. First Nat’l Bank, etc., 137 Ind. 698; Hauch, Treas., etc., v. Terre Haute Brewing Co., 137 Ind. 698; Hauck, Treas., etc., v. First Nat’l Bank, etc., 138 Ind. 700; Conzman, Treas., etc., v. Terre Haute Brewing Co., 138 Ind.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.