Court of Appeals of Kansas December 4, 1895, No. 61 (Butler v. Cooper)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1895

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Johnson, P. J.:

This was an action in replevin to recover possession of two horses, one two-horse buggy, and one set of double buggy harness, all of the value of $325, commenced by Maria S. Butler against J. B. Cooper and M. L. Conley in the district court of Montgomery county. The petition of the plaintiff alleged that she was the owner of the property and entitled to the immediate possession of the same, and that, it was wrongfully detained from her by defendants. Upon filing the necessary affidavit and executing an undertaking in replevin, an order of delivery *146was issued, and the property taken under the order of delivery and delivered to the plaintiff. The defendant M. L. Conley filed his separate answer, disclaiming any interest in the property, and denying that he detained the property or that he ever had it in his possession. The defendant J. B. Cooper filed his separate answer, containing a general denial of the allegations in the petition of the plaintiff, except as to the value of the property and that he refused to deliver the possession of the property to the plaintiff; there was a second defense by way of affirmative relief set up by this defendant, to which it is unnecessary to refer in this case, as there was no evidence tending to prove the same and no finding made thereon.

The case was tried before the court and jury on these issues, and resulted in a verdict finding that the defendants did not wrongfully detain the horses described in plaintiff’s petition, that the defendants’ interest in said horses was $159.24, and that at the commencement of the action the plaintiff was the owner of the buggy and harness described in her petition, and entitled to the immediate possession of the same, and that the same were wrongfully detained from her by the defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.