New York Court of Appeals December 1, 1896 (Rowell v. . Janvrin)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-12-1896
O’Brien, J.
This was an action against a stockholder of a corporation organized under the Manufacturing Act of 1848 to enforce a debt of the corporation, upon the ground that no certificate that the capital stock had been paid in was ever made or filed as required by the tenth and eleventh sections of the act. The complaint was dismissed at the trial on the ground that it did not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action, and this ruling, and the exception taken by the plaintiff, raises the only question that need now be considered.
The complaint alleges that the certificate required by the sections of the act above referred to was not filed or recorded, but it was held that this allegation was not sufficient to charge the defendant. While the complaint alleges generally that the defendant was a stockholder, there is no statement as to
*64
the amount or number of shares that he held, and this was another defect which was stated in the motion to dismiss. ¡No other objection appears to have been made to the sufficiency of the complaint, and no other features of the pleading are attacked, and the discussion is, therefore, confined to these two points.
The more substantial ground upon which the defendant succeeded in the courts below was that the complaint failed to state whether the stock was issued for cash or for property. It is said that if the stock was issued for property there was no duty or obligation to file any certificate whatever, while if issued for money, then the statute applied, but the plaintiff was bound to state a case in his pleading which brought the defendant within the statute.
This contention calls for a construction of the statute upon which the action is based.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit