Supreme Court of North Carolina September 5, 1896 (Morgan v. . Roper)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-09-1896
ClarK, J.:
The plaintiff sues upon an itemized account (made a part of the complaint) for goods sold and delivered to the defendant, aggregating $630.90, admitting
*368
credits amounting to $295.43, and asking judgment for the balance of $345.47, which it is averred the defendant promised to pay. The defendant, answering, denies promising to pay the alleged balance. He admits the purchase and receipt of the items in plaintiff’s account, to the amount of $259.48, specifying which they are; and as to the other items of plaintiff’s account, he avers that he
“
has no knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief, and therefore denies the same.” This is in the very words of the denial in such cases authorized by
The
Code, Sec. 243 (1), and puts the plaintiff on proof of his account,
(Bank
v.
Charlotte,
75 N. C., 45,) outside of the admitted items, amounting to $259.48, and against that amount are the plaintiff’s admitted credits of $295.43 ; besides, the defendant pleads additional payments by him to the amount of $151, which “ are not entered among the credits on plaintiff’s statement.”
The court below made the mistake of applying the credits, admitted by the plaintiff, to the items of debit denied by the defendant. Applying the admitted credits to the admitted debits, there was no balance admitted by the defendant for which judgment could be entered. The plaintiff must go on and prove his disputed items of account, and it will devolve upon the defendant to prove his allegations of additional payments, for not being pleaded as a counter-claim, they are taken as denied.
Code,
Sec. 268 ; Clark’s Code (2nd. Ed.), p. 215.
The case relied upon by the plaintiff
(Gas Co.
v.
Mfg. Co.,
91 N. C.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit