Supreme Court of North Carolina September 5, 1896 (Deaver v. . Jones)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-09-1896

Avert, J.:

The court instructed the jury that when a grant is located by contemporaneous marked lines those contemporaneous marked lines govern and control its bonudary and fix the location so as to supersede other descriptions.

We

see no merit in the exception to this as

*599

a legal proposition. A deed is a contract, and the highest evidence of the identity of the subject-matter of it, where there is conflicting testimony as to its true location, is proof of the consent of two minds that certain marked lines or corners should constitute the boundary.

Shaffer

v.

Gaynor,

117 N. C., 15 ;

Shultz

v. Young, 3 Ired., at pp. 385, 388 ;

Baxter

v.

Wilson,

95 N. C., 137, at pp. 143, 144;

Cooper

v.

White,

1 Jones, 389;

Manufacturing Company

v.

Hendricks,

106 N. C., 485;

Bonaparte

v.

Garter,

Ibid., 534. Whenever it can be proved that there was a line already run by the surveyor, was marked and a corner made, the party claiming under the patent or deed shall hold accordingly.

Cherry

v.

Slade,

3 Murphy, at p. 82. While it is the mle that a call for a natural object, such as a stream or a line of another tract of land located by extrinsic testimony, will control course and distance so as to prolong a line till it reaches the object,

(Buckner

v.

Anderson, supra; Corn

v.

McCrary,

3 Jones, 496,) it is equally true that if the jury find from the evidence that an object, such as a stone or tree called for as a corner, was actually agreed upon by the parties at the time of the execution of the deed, though it may be reached before the distance gives out, or before intersecting with another line which is also called for, such tree or stone must be declared the true corner.

Bonaparte

v.

Carter

and

Buckner

v.

Anderson, supra; Murray

v.

Spencer,

88 N. C., 357. Where common reputation has pointed to an object for years as .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.