U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Pennsylvania June 16, 1896 (Bennett v. Schooley)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-06-1896

BUFFINGTON, District Judge.

On August 27, 1889, patent No. 409,902 issued to Walter O. Beckwith for a railway torpedo. TMs patent was subsequently assigned to complainants, who file this bill for the alleged infringement by respondent of three claims thereof. The controversy relates to railway torpedoes, which are small tin shells or cases, charged with an explosive compound. These are placed on the rails, and attached thereto. Trains passing along ex*393plode them, by which the engineer is notified of danger or obstructions ahead. The; torpedo is attached to the rail by a wire or lead strip which laps or is turned up under the shoulder of the rail. Prior to the patent in suit such strips or wires were soldered or riveted to the tin torpedo cáse before the torpedo was charged. The operation was tedious, and required skilled labor. In the subsequent operation of filling the case the strip was liable to be tom off, as, indeed, it was in the handling, shipment, or use of the torpedo by the manufacturer or user. If this happened, another strip could not, without serious danger, be riveted or soldered to the shell, and in practice it was never done. The torpedo became a “cull” or rejected one. By the method shown in the patent in suit, which was both simple and effective, these difficulties were overcome, and certain other advantages gained. Prom the proofs, Beckwith, the patentee, seems to have been the first to conceive the idea of loosely attaching or securing the lead or wire to the torpedo, instead of positively uniting it thereto, as was the previous practice, by solder or wire. The means he thus employed served also to hold the case and cover of the torpedo together. To carry out his invention, he suggested in his specification several alternative methods. In the sloping torpedo of oblong shape he provided flanges on the lower opposite edges.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.