Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 15, 1897 (Walton v. Stafford)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1897
Babrett, J.:
The sole question here is as to the validity of the defendants* counterclaim. Were they, upon the agreed facts, entitled to recover from the plaintiff, in his «representative capacity, the rent payable upon the first day of January ? The plaintiff, being an assignee for the benefit of creditors, had an election to accept or decline the lease. .He had a reasonable time to ascertain whether this lease *312could "be made available for the benefit of the creditors whom he represented. If, thereupon, he found that the term, burdened with the j>ayment of rent and the performance of other conditions, was" an interest of no value; that instead of being a benefit it would probably, diminish the amount to which the creditors would otherwise be entitled, his duty was to decline the lease. If, however, his investigation led him to believe that the lease-was a valuable asset, he could, as, in fact, he did, accept it. (Journeay v. Brackley, ' 1 Hilt. 447.) Hpon its acceptance it became a part of' the assigned estate, held by the assignee in his. trust capacity subject to the covenants contained therein. "While it was so held the assignee, in his representative: capacity, was chargeable with all the conditions attached thereto. It was not his contract, either personal or as representative^ and his liability upon the covenants was, consequently, not contractual. That liability was the liability of his assignor’s estate, legally resulting from its acquisition of the lease as an asset. It was, therefore, the plaintiff’s liability as assignee.
In the present case the assignee accepted the lease and utilized the demised premises for the benefit of his cestuis que.i/riost. Privity of estate was thus established, and as -a sequence the plaintiff’s liability as assignée for the rent falling due during the period of his occupation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit