Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 15, 1897 (Schloss v. Schloss)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1897

.Rumsey, J.:

The facts in this case do not differ materially from those which were made to appear in The Matter of Thompson (10 App. Div. 40), which was an application by a judgment creditor of these same parties for the- same relief which is here asked. We concluded, upon a careful examination of the facts in that case, that as a matter of fact they did not show insolvency on the part of the firm of Schloss & Sons, and that the judgment creditor should be permitted to' collect his debt in the same manner as other judgment creditors -of other debtors. In view of the fact that this motion was denied by the learned judge at Special Term, after a like motion bad been .-granted by this court in The Matter of Thompson, we have examined the affidavits in this case with great particularity, for the purpose * of satisfying ourselves whether, upon all the facts, it has been shown that the firm of Schloss & Sons was insolvent, and as a result of that examination we reach now the same conclusion which we reached before, that no such condition of affairs is shown as would warrant a holding that the firm was insolvent so as to refuse to a diligent ■creditor the right to collect his debt. The decision in The Matter of Thompson (supra), therefore, controls this case and requires the reversal of this order and the granting of the motion.

We have been referred upon the argument-of this motion to the case of Myers v. Myers, cited at the Special Term and reported in the Law Journal for December 31, 1896. The rule laid down in that case does not differ from the case of Thompson, and it proceeds *335entirely upon the ground that in the particular case the judgment debtors were insolvent, and that the court was at liberty, in view of all the facts, to devote their property to the satisfaction of their debts pro rata among all their creditors. That is not the case here, and for that reason the case of Myers v. Myers does not apply.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.