Indiana Supreme Court February 5, 1897, No. 18,104 (Warford v. Sullivan)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1897

McCabe, J.

The appellant sued the appellees to foreclose a mortgage executed to the appellee, Huston, to indemnify him as surety on two promissory notes of |5,000.00 each, executed to appellant by appellee, Sullivan and wife, and Mackey as principals, and said Huston as surety, containing also a covenant to pay said notes to appellant, Warford.

The only controversy in this case on this appeal is between the appellant and one of the appellees, the First National Bank of Evansville, Indiana, over that part of the decree rendered upon the cross-complaint filed by said bank.

.That cross-complaint sought and obtained a decree declaring said bank the holder of a superior lien to that of . the appellant by reason of said bank having become a redemptioner of 400 acres of the land embraced in the appellant’s mortgage.

The errors assigned call in question the action of the trial court in overruling appellant’s motion -for a new trial of the issues between said bank and appel*16lant, in decreeing that the lien of the judgment of said bank was prior and superior to the lien of the appellant’s mortgage on the real estate described in the decree, and in decreeing a sale of said real estate on a venditioni exponas by said appellee, and directing that from such sale said appellee should be first paid before appellant should receive anything on said mortgage, and questioning the sufficiency of the facts stated in the cross-complaint of said appellee bank.

The first and last assignment present the same question. There is no question made that the facts stated in the cross-complaint were not proven. If the cross-complaint stated facts sufficient, such facts having been proven, the motion for a new trial was properly overruled and the proper decree was rendered.

The controversy then is simply a question of law. That question depends upon the proper construction of the statute of redemptions of 1881.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.