Indiana Supreme Court November 4, 1897, No. 18,100 (Jamison v. Lake Erie & Western Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1897

Monks, J.

This action was brought by appellant to review a judgment obtained by appellee against appellant. Appellee’s demurrer to the complaint, for want of facts, was sustained, and, appellant refusing to plead further, judgment was rendered against ap*522pellant. The only error assigned calls in question the action of the court in sustaining the demurrer to the complaint. Appellee insists that under the provisions of section 365, Burns’ R. S. 1894 (362, R. S. 1881), it is only when a pleading is founded upon a written instrument or account that the same can be made a part of the pleading by filing the original, or a copy, with such pleading; that an action to review a judgment is not brought upon such judgment, or to recover thereon, but to review the same for error; and that, therefore, the part of the record sought to be reviewed cannot be made a part of the complaint by filing the same therewith as an exhibit; that, as the part of the record sought to be reviewed was not set forth in the complaint, but was only filed therewith as an exhibit, the court did not err in sustaining the demurrer thereto.

We need not, and do not, however, determine whether or not it is necessary, as insisted by appellee, to set forth in a complaint for review a copy of the part of the record sought to be reviewed, for the reason that,” conceding that it is not necessary, and that a copy of the same may be filed with the complaint as an exhibit, the coinplaint in this case was not, for ■other reasons urged by appellee, sufficient to withstand the demurrer for want of facts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.