Indiana Supreme Court September 22, 1897, No. 18,103 (Barnard v. Shirley)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-09-1897
McCabe, C. J.
The appellee sued the appellants to recover damages for, and to restrain them from causing cer’falh' mineral water coming from defendants' well to flow through a certain spring branch adjoining plaintiff’s land, by which the waters of said branch are befouled to the plaintiff’s injury. The issues made were tried by the court, resulting in a, finding and judgment against the defendants, according to the prayer of the complaint. That judgment was, on appeal to this court, reversed for error in sustaining a demurrer to the second paragraph of defendants’ an-I swer. Barnard v. Shirley, 135 Ind. 547, 24 L. E. A. 568. On the return of the case to the circuit court the issues-, were again tried, resulting in a special finding of the facts, upon which the court stated its conclusions of law, upon which it rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiff, both for damages and enjoining the defendants, as prayed for in the complaint.
The substance of the special finding by the court is: That the land described in the complaint, situate adjoining the city of Martinsville, was purchased by plaintiff from Lafayette Sims on May 10, 1886, and plaintiff has ever since held and possessed the samel *162That said Sims owned and occupied said lands for years before; that said defendant, Elizabeth Barnard, has owned the lots described in the complaint, numbers twenty and thirty, in the original plat of the town of Martinsville, Morgan county, Indiana, since the year 1868, and still owns the same; that, at the time of selling, and delivering to plaintiff the lands above described, said Sims also sold and delivered to her 160 acres lying about one mile to the northeast of said first described land, .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit