Michigan Supreme Court September 14, 1897 (People v. Dunn)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-1897

Long, C. J.

The respondent was informed against jointly with one Humes in the Saginaw circuit for the larceny of a buggy valued at $40. On a separate trial before a jury he was convicted of the offense.

It appears that Humes, on September 15, 1895, rented a buggy from one George W. Hill, a liveryman at Saginaw, for the afternoon of that day. He and respondent drove around that city for a time that afternoon, when Humes became intoxicated, was arrested, and taken to jail. Respondent then drove with the buggy to Bay City, where he traded it off for another. The defense interposed was that respondent had nothing to do with the *356renting of the buggy from Hill, but, after it was rented, he purchased it from Humes, paying $7.50; that he acted in good faith in selling it, believing that Humes had a right to sell it to him. These questions were left to the jury by the trial court, as follows:

“His claim is that he bought this buggy for $7.50; that he bought it of Humes; that, after he had purchased it, he, with this woman who has been a witness here, after driving about town for awhile, drove to Bay City, and did not come back, and he disposed of it. If you find as a matter of fact that, although he had no right to take it, if he honestly believed that Humes had a right to sell him the buggy, and he did buy it of him, then he would not be guilty of larceny, even if he did take it and Humes had no right to it. * * * But if he sold it without any color of right, and did not believe that he had any right or authority to do so, then your verdict would be 1 Guilty.’ ”

It is contended by counsel that there is no proof in the case that the respondent was present when the buggy was hired from Hill, that the testimony all tends to show that he bought it from Humes, and that he acted in good faith in selling it at Bay City. We cannot agree with counsel’s contention.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.