Supreme Court of Minnesota January 18, 1897, Nos. 10,211—(219) (Board of County Commissioners v. Duluth, Red Wing & Southern Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-1897

COLLINS, J.2

The defendant company built its railway in the year 1888 through a valley in which ran a very sinuous stream, known as “Hay Greek.” The creek was crossed by a county road, and the public authorities had built and maintained a bridge over it for many years. To avoid the construction of two bridges over the creek, defendant company cut a ditch about 100 feet long on the easterly side of, and within, its right of way, from a point above to a point below the highway, whereby the waters of the creek were *215turned from tlie natural channel into an artificial one, wholly on the right of way. Along the highway the new channel was about 150 feet from the old, and at the point where the highway intersected the raihvay the latter was on a 15-foot grade; the creek, in its new channel, running close to the embankment. The company made an approach to the top of the grade by building a bridge, commencing at a point about 19 feet from the center of the track, and extending it easterly along the center of the highway, across the creek, to the high land, a few feet east of the easterly line of its right of way. It did nothing with the old bridge, and two or three years afterwards the public authorities removed it, and put in a box culvert and some earth in the old bed of the stream.

The approach and bridge built by defendant were partly or wholly destroyed by a flood in 1890, and were then rebuilt by it. They were again destroyed by a flood in 1895, and, although duly notified and required to rebuild by the authorities, the defendant refused so to do. The approach and bridge were then put in by the county, and this was an action to recover the cost of the same. The verdict was in favor of the plaintiff for the full amount, and defendant appeals from an order denying its motion for a new trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.