Supreme Court of the United States November 29, 1897, 84 (Dennison v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-11-1897
Mn. Justice Shown
delivered the opinion of the court.
The duties of Chief Supervisors are prescribed by statute.. Eev. Stat. § 2020 and § 2026. Their fees are also fixed by statute. § 2031. To entitle a supervisor to a valid claim' against the Government he must make it appear that the services performed were required by the letter of the former sections, or were such as were actually and necessarily performed in the proper execution of the duties therein prescribed. It must also appear that his charges therefor are covered by the latter section, or if they are not fixed in the very words of that section, that, by analogy to some other service, he is entitled to make a corresponding charge. If the services are only performed for his own convenience, or are manifestly unnecessary or useless — even if they be such as he judges proper himself — theycannot.be made the basis of a claim against the Government.
*243
The petitioner in this case made a claim for his services in the general elections of 1890 and 1892 in the aggregate sum of $35,611.73, of which but $4265.13 appear to have been for disbursements. Of this very large amount there' was disallowed but $5334.35, an amount which was further reduced by the judgment in his favor of $678.10 to $4656.25, which is the amount in dispute here.
If the petitioner be entitled by law to the further sum claimed for what are in the main clerical services, he must receive judgment for them; but as the dates of the approval of his accounts show that his services did not extend over a period of more than six months, he has at least no reason to complain of the illiberality of the Government.
The approval of the District Court goes only to the facts that the services were rendered as stated in the accounts, and that in certain matters of discretion, the discretion was properly exercised.
United States
v. Jones, 134 U. S. 483 ;
United States
v. Barber, 140 U. S. 177, 179.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit