Washington Supreme Court October 15, 1898, No. 2963 (J. F. Hart Lumber Co. v. Everett Land Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1898

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Scott, C. J.

In December, 1891, the defendant leased to the plaintiff a piece of land on the west hank of the Snohomish river, for a certain stipulated rental, for the period of five- years. The controversy in this action arises over the construction to be given the following clause, contained in the lease:

“At the expiration of the above mentioned term of five years the said first party shall pay to the said second party the actual value of any wharf or dock which said second party may have placed in the river in front of the hereby demised premises, it being understood and agreed that said first party is not to pay for any improvements which may have been made on said premises hereby demised west of the hank of said river, or for anything except the actual cost of making a dock or wharf in front of said premises, said appraisement to be made in the following manner: Each party to this agreement shall choose one *73appraiser and in case said appraisers cannot agree, they two shall choose a third and his decision shall he final and conclusive.”

Under that clause, the plaintiff claimed the right to recover either the cost of the wharf, in 1891, or the cost of a similar wharf, in 1896, at the expiration of the term. The defendant contended that there could he a recovery only for the actual value of the wharf at the expiration of the lease, not exceeding its cost. The action was brought to recover the cost of the wharf when constructed, and the complaint contained no allegation of its value at the expiration of the lease. A demurrer to the complaint having been sustained and judgment rendered thereon, the plaintiff has appealed. The clause in question is contradictory in first speaking of the value and next of the cost of the wharf; but we are of the opinion that the respondent’s contention should prevail, for the lease provided that appraisers should he appointed, and evidently they were to determine the value of the wharf.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.