Nebraska Supreme Court June 23, 1898, No. 8160 (Allsman v. Richmond)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-06-1898

Sullivan, J.

In this action Eugene Richmond sued John L., Allsinan and John W. Allsman to recover for services rendered in training, driving, and caring for a racing stallion during the racing season of 1894. The cause was tried before a justice of the peace of Saline county and resulted in a judgment against both defendants. From this judgment John W. Allsman alone appealed and filed in the district court a general denial to the petition. Upon the issues joined a trial was had to a jury and the plaintiff was again successful. The defendant John W. prosecutes error to this court, and among the assignments insists that the verdict is not sustained by sufficient evidence.

The horse was owned by John W., and managed by his son, John L., with'whom the contract of hiring was originally made. The theory of the defense was that the elder Allsman had given his son the exclusive use of the stallion for the season of 1894, and that the latter was to have complete charge of him, be responsible for his entire care and management, and receive his entire earnings. Much evidence ivas adduced in support of this theory, while the plaintiff, to establish the liability of John W., testified as follows:

On the 28th of July, 1894, I made an agreement with John L. Allsman to train and drive Ms horse, “Charles Birch.” He represented to me that he was the owner of the horse and I was to receive $25 a month and my expenses during the racing season of 1894. I took the horse and went to work with him. Some three or four days after that I was in the stall with the horse and a *542gentleman came in and was looking at the horsé. I did not know him, or who he was. He commenced to talk abont the horse, and I went on to tell him what the horse was and what his name was, like I would to any stranger —liked to recommend him. He says, “I know all about this horse. I know this horse.” He says, “I own this horse.” I said, “This young man that I hired to said, he owned the horse — J. L. Allsman.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.