Indiana Supreme Court November 18, 1898, No. 18,499 (Davis v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-11-1898

McCabe, J.

The appellant was tried by a jury in the Clark Ciicuit Court on an indictment charging him with an assault perpetrated April 13, 1896, on one Thomas Glynn, with the felonious intent to murder the said Glynn. The jury found appellant “guilty of the crime charged in the indictment, and that he be fined in the sum of $50, and that his age is fifty-four years.” On this verdict the circuit court rendered judgment that he be confined in the state prison not less than two and not more than fourteen years, and for the fine of $50 and costs, over appellant’s motions for a new trial, for a venire de novo, and in arrest of jridgment. The assignment of errors calls in question these several rulings as the sole grounds on which a reversal of the judgment is sought. Under the motions for a venire de novo and in arrest of judgment, it is contended by appellant that the act approved March 8, 1897, the only law authorizing such a verdict and judgment, known as the indeterminate sentence law, is unconstitutional as to this case, because, as applied to this case, it is an ex post facto law, the alleged crime having been committed before the passage of the act. The constitutionality of the act in all other respects has recently been upheld by this court in Vancleave v. State, 150 Ind. 273; Wilson v. State, 150 Ind. 697; Miller v. State, 149 Ind. 607, 40 L. R. A. 109.

■ Section 24 of article 1 of the bill of rights in the Constitution provides that “No ex post facto law * * * shall be passed.” Section 69 Burns 1894, section 69 Homer 1897. The question is what is an ex post facto law? This court,.as *36far back as 1822, defined tbe meaning of the phrase as follows: “The words ex post facto have a definite, technical signification.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.