Indiana Court of Appeals May 19, 1898, No. 2,464 (Tebbs v. Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1898

Comstock, J.

The complaint alleges that a bill of lading was issued by the C., C., C. & St. L. Ry Co. to J. Leverone & Co. for one car load of bananas, and that the car was consigned to appellant under the name of Tebbs Bros;, at Anderson, Indiana. The bill of lading contains the following clause, “with privilege of stopping over at Greensburg and Rushville, Ind.” The breach of the contract upon which the complaint counts is that the appellee refused to stop the car either at Greensburg or Rushville. The court below sustained a demurrer to the complaint for want of facts to constitute a cause of action. This ruling of the court is the error assigned upon appeal.

Omitting formal portions of the complaint, it is as follows: That on and prior to August 29, 1894, plaintiff was engaged in doing business under the firm name of Tebbs Bros., and selling bananas in the markets to merchants and grocers along the line of defendant’s railway in the cities of Greensburg, Rush-ville and Anderson; and prior to said 29th day of Au-. gust, 1894, had arranged to sell in the markets in each of said cities in Indiana, and had arranged to procure from the city of Cincinnati, Ohio, a car load of bananas, and ship the same through said cities of Greensburg, Rushville and Anderson, with the privilege of stopping over at each of said places and sell to *194customers in such markets, and that on or about said 29th day of August, 1894, he purchased of defendants, J. Leverone & Company, of Cincinnati, Ohio, a car load of bananas for the purpose of making such shipment, which car load of bananas was of the value of $350.00, and of good merchantable and marketable condition and quality, and caused said J. Leverone & Company on said day to ship said car load of bananas so purchased from them, over the defendant’s railway, with the privilege of stopping over at said cities of Greensburg and Rushville, to be consigned to plaintiff at said city of Anderson, and said J. Leverone & Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.