Supreme Court of Minnesota December 22, 1898, Nos. 11,289—(156) (Fort Dearborn National Bank v. Seymour)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1898

CANTY, J.

This is the second appeal in this action. On the first trial the court found for the plaintiff bank, and we held that the evidence would not sustain a judgment in its favor. For a statement of the facts appearing by the evidence on that trial, see opinion on former appeal, 71 Minn. 81, 73 N. W. 724. On the second trial the court found for defendants, and plaintiff appeals from an order denying a new trial.

Appellant contends that the evidence will not sustain a judgment for defendants.

On the second trial the evidence was in some respects materially different from what it was on the first trial. And in discussing the evidence given on the second trial it must be remembered that the question now is, not whether that evidence would sustain a judgment for plaintiff, but whether it will sustain a judgment for defendants. It may be that this evidence would sustain a judgment for either party, and that the finding of the trial court for the defendants should be sustained. It was fairly to be implied from the *102evidence on the first trial that the check given by the Gladstone Land Company in payment of its note to the Stillwater Bank was not paid by the Bank of Minnesota until after the arrangements were made by William Dawson, Jr., with plaintiff to take the new note of the Land Company, and that the Bank of Minnesota then paid the check on the faith of these arrangements. But it appears by the evidence on the second trial that this check was paid before any such arrangements were made.

On the afternoon of July 12, 1893, Bronson, the cashier of the Stillwater Bank, appeared in St. Paul after banking hours, and presented the note to Dawson, Jr., as treasurer of the Land Company, for payment. Thereupon Dawson, Jr., as such treasurer, drew a check on the Bank of Minnesota for $25,019.44 in favor of the Still-water Bank, delivered the check to Bronson, and received from him the notes of the Land Company.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.