California Supreme Court November 11, 1899, L.A. No. 486. (County of Los Angeles v. Spencer)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-11-1899
GRAY, C.
—The plaintiff appeals from a judgment following an order sustaining a demurrer to an amended complaint without leave to further amend.
The amended complaint purports td set out a cause of action to foreclose a lien for the expense of abating an insect pest nuisance in defendants’ orchard. This lien is claimed to exist by virtue of an act entitled, "An act to protect and promote the horticultural interest of the state,” and acts amendatory thereof and additional thereto. The act in question may be found in the Statutes of 1881, page 88, and the amendments and additions thereto in the Statutes of 1889, page 413, and the Statutes of 1891, pages 260 and 268. In sustaining the demurrer without leave to amend, the learned judge of the court below filed an opinion, in which the principal reason assigned for the action of the court is that the act in question is unconstitutional, and this, also, is the main reason urged on this appeal in support of the judgment. It is said, first, that the act embraces more than one subject grouped under one title. The act as amended provides for the appointment, by the board of supervisors of any county in the state to whom the required petition is presented, of a horticultural commission of not exceeding three members. It also prescribes the length of the terms of office of said commissioners and the manner of filling vacancies therein. It then defines the duties' and powers of the board of horticultural commissioners, fixes their compensation, and provides for their removal. It makes the expense of removing or abating an insect pest nuisance from any property infested thereby a lien upon the property or premises from which such nuisance has been abated. All the duties and powers conferred upon said board appertain to the abating of those insect pest nuisances which interfere with the business of horticulture.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit