Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 5, 1899 (Smith v. Wells)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1899
Blodgett, C. J.
Gordon was a competent witness. He was not a party of record, nor was he a party in interest within the language or intent of the statute (P. S.,
c.
224,
s.
16) excluding the testimony of a party where the adverse party is an administrator, etc., and declines to testify.
To disqualify a person as a witness against an administrator under this statute, it must be shown “ that he is the party in interest, — the party who really carries on the controversy, under a party who has no interest in it, and is merely a nominal party, or under one who is fully indemnified. ”
Townsend
v.
Riley,
46 N. H. 300, 308, 309;
English
v.
Porter,
63 N. H. 206, 215. He must be directly interested in the subject-matter of the suit, and have “ a right to make defence, or to control the proceedings, and to appeal from the judgment. This right involves also the right to adduce testimony, and to cross-examine tho witnesses adduced on
*52
tibe other side. Persons not having these rights are regarded as. strangers to the cause; ” 1 Gr. Ev.,
s.
523;
Carlton
v.
Patterson,
29 N. H. 580;
Wheeler
v.
Towns,
43 N. H. 56, 57.
Upon the principles of these as well as other authorities, Gordon cannot properly be regarded as a party simply because he is the-residuary legatee of the original payee of the note and gave bond to pay her debts and legacies. His indirect and contingent liability, if any, to pay the note, gave him no right to make defence to the pending suit, “to control the proceedings, to appeal from the judgment, or to take exceptions to the rulings of the court, produce testimony or cross-examine witnesses,” nor make him hable for costs.
Wheeler
v.
Towns, supra.
At most, the objection to his-testimony goes to its weight merely. Nor do we preceive any objection to that part of it which was admitted subject to special exception.
The plaintiff’s exception to the admission of the defendant’s, plea of the statute of limitations is overruled. Its allowance was.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit