New York Court of Appeals January 10, 1899 (Laidlaw v. . Sage)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-01-1899
Martin, J.
This action was commenced May 26, 1892. Its purpose was to recover for personal injuries sustained by
*78
the plaintiff in consequence of an explosion which occurred in the defendant’s office in the city of R6w York on the fourth day of December, 1891. There is no allegation in the complaint, nor was there any proof upon the trial, which even tended to show that the defendant was in any way responsible for the explosion which was the cause of the plaintiff’s injury.
The evidence disclosed that a stranger, whose name was subsequently found to be Rorcross, called at the defendant’s office December 4, 1891, at about ten minutes past twelve o’clock, said he desired to see the defendant in relation to some railroad bonds and had a letter of introduction from Hr. Rockefeller. When asked to send it to the defendant, he stated that he preferred to present it in person and that he only wanted to say two or three words. Upon receiving this message, the defendant stepped from his private office into the ante room, went to the window and looked into the lobby, where he saw Rorcross sitting upon a settee. At that time the defendant met the plaintiff, who said he had a message-from Hr. Bloódgood, and the defendant thereupon turned the knob of the door and the plaintiff passed into the ante room of the office. The former then spoke to Rorcross, who instantly arose, took his carpet bag in his left hand, and, approaching him, handed him a letter which was supposed to be from Hr. Rockefeller, which he took, opened and read. It was a typewritten communication, the substance of which was: “ The bag I hold in my hand contains tpn pounds of dynamite. If I drop this bag on the floor, the dynamite will explode and destroy this building in ruins, and kill every human being in the building. I demand $1,200,000, or I will drop the bag. Will you give it ? Yes or no ?
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit