Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 15, 1899 (Fox v. Davidson)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1899

Ingraham, J. :

The defendant applied to the court below for a bill of particulars as to several of the allegations of the complaint. The complaint alleged the making óf a contract between the plaintiff and the defendant; that there was a breach of the contract by the defendant ; that subsequently the defendant requested the plaintiff to proceed with the said work and promised that if he would do so the defendant would deliver to the plaintiff certain notes. The defendant asked for a bill of particulars of the time and' place when this *284new agreement was alleged to have been made. We think the plaintiff was entitled to such bill of particulars. The allegation as to the new agreement is extremely indefinite. The time and place at which it was made were not stated, and it would he manifestly unsafe for the plaintiff to proceed to trial unless he could have such particulars. The complaint also alleged that the defendant waived the provisions in the said agreement providing that the said premises should he completed by November 1, 1896, and that the premises should be erected to the satisfaction and under the direction of .'the architect mentioned in said agreement; that the value of additions to or omissions from the work provided for by said contract, should be stipulated in writing and signed by the parties to said ' agreement; and that the payments and other considerations mentioned in said agreement should be made to the plaintiff, provided-a certificate should he obtained and signed by the said architect when each of the considerations should become due. We think that the defendant was entitled to a bill of particulars specifying the act or acts or statements from which such waivers as are alleged in the 4th paragraph of the complaint could be implied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.