Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court February 28, 1899 (Daley v. People's Building, Loan, & Savings Ass'n)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-02-1899
Holmes, J.
This is an action upon a covenant to pay one hundred dollars a share, five years from date, contained in a certificate that the plaintiff is a shareholder in the defendant corporation. At the trial the defendant offered evidence that there were withdrawals of other members on file, that the corporation had suffered losses since the certificate was issued, and that the directors had taken steps to reduce the assets, the object being, of course, to show that the corporation had not funds applicable to the payment of the alleged debt. The evidence was rejected. The defendant also moved for.a nonsuit, on the ground that by the conditions of the contract any action brought by a shareholder was required to be brought in the county of Ontario, in the State of New York. This was refused. The plaintiff had a verdict, and the case is here on exceptions.
As we understand that a decision upon the first poipt mentioned is likely to dispose of the case, we shall confine ourselves to that, and shall not decide the second, although, if we were prepared to assent to the defendant’s contention without further consideration, it would be logical to dismiss the plaintiff to New York. Compare Nute v. Hamilton Ins. Co. 6 Gray, 174, 179, 184, with Greve v. Ætna Live Stock Ins. Co. 81 Hun, 28.
With regard to the evidence offered, the plaintiff takes the preliminary objection that it does not appear what the defendant expected to prove. Shinners v. Proprietors of Locks & Canals, 154 Mass. 168, 169. But the rule referred to is a rule of substance, not of form. There must be reasonable ground to believe that the excepting party has been harmed by the exclusion of a question, but there need not be a formal tender of proof. In this case, the series of questions put and excluded showed the defendant’s purpose and expectation so clearly that it would be unjust not to deal with the offer of evidence-on its merits.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit