Supreme Court of Colorado September 15, 1899, No. 4094 (Messenger v. Northcutt)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1899
Per Curiam.
On the ground that the district court of Bent county, in an action for the claim and delivery of per*528sonal property, replevin under the old procedure, wherein J. H. Jones is plaintiff and Kemron E. Messenger is defendant, has abused, and, if permitted to proceed further, will greatly abuse, its discretion, the petitioner here (defendant there) asks this court to stop further action.
The ruling complained of already made was an order denying defendant’s motion to strike from the files the amended complaint, based upon the ground that therein was set up a new cause of action, and one entirely different from that contained in the original complaint. The alleged abuse of discretion threatened is the avowed intention of the trial court, declared when the foregoing order was entered, to proceed to a trial upon this new and substituted cause of action, when, under prior decisions of this court, it has been held that a plaintiff, against defendant’s objection, may not, by way of an amendment to the complaint, introduce a new cause of action. It is claimed that there is no other adequate remedy to review this ruling because it is waived by answering over (citing Scovill v. Glasner, 79 Mo. 449), and defendant ought not to be required to risk his rights by standing on his motion, and depend for a reversal of the final judgment, rendered on default, solely upon the error assigned to the ruling on the motion. The departure is said to be that whereas in the original complaint the plaintiff sued in the capacity as agent of the owner of the property, in the amended pleading he sues as the owner himself.
We must not be understood as intimating, even if plaintiff’s construction of the pleadings is correct, that prohibition would lie, for that question is not before us. We are clearly of opinion that the cause of action set up in the amended pleading is the same as that first alleged.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit