Indiana Supreme Court November 28, 1899, No. 18,708 (Butler v. Thornburgh)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-11-1899

Jordan, J.

Appellant commenced this action in the lower court to secure an accounting in respeet to rents and *531profits arising out of certain described real estate, and to redeem her alleged interest in the realty in question from the lien of a purchase-money mortgage.

Appellees successfully demurred to the complaint, and judgment was rendered upon demurrer; and the only error presented relates to the sufficiency of the complaint upon demurrer.

The facts appear to be as follows: Rollin T. Butler, and appellant Martha Butler, were in 1881, and still are, husband and wife. In September of that year the husband, Rollin T., purchased and became the owner of the land described in the complaint, situated in Henry county, Indiana. In order to pay the purchase money thereof, said Rollin T. borrowed of one Milton Thornburgh about $8,000, and, to secure payment thereof, he mortgaged the land which he had purchased. Appellant did not join her husband in the execution of this mortgage. Thornburgh, upon the maturity of the mortgage debt, commenced an action in the Henry Circuit Court' against this appellant and her said husband to foreclose the mortgage, and recover a personal judgment against the husband for the sum of $5,000, and obtained a decree against both for the foreclosure of the mortgage. It is further disclosed by the complaint that appellant appealed from said judgment to the Supreme Court of Indiana, and that such proceedings were had therein that the judgment below was by this court in all things reversed as to her. (Butler v. Thornburgh, 131 Ind. 237.) After the appeal in question, and during its pendency, Thornburgh caused the land to be sold, under the decree, at sheriffs sale, and he became the purchaser thereof for the full amount of his judgment. After the expiration of one year from the date of sa'id sale, but before the appeal to this court had been determined, he took possession of the land so purchased by him, and some time thereafter died.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.