Supreme Court of Iowa October 7, 1899 (Ringen Stove Co. v. Bowers)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-10-1899

Ladd, J.

The assignee for the benefit of creditors is not only a trustee for them, but for the assignor as well, who retains a contingent interest in the estate. The balance remaining after the satisfaction of debts and expenses of administration belongs to the assignor. His interest may be likened to that of the mortgagor of personal property. He is interested, then, in the minimum allowance being made on claims filed, and in the maximum amount being received on debts due and for goods sold. The interest of the assignee, as the trustee of both debtor and creditor-, to this extent is identical with that of the assignor. Indeed, this is always true, save when the assignee peculiarly represents the creditor in attempting to remedy a prior wrong of the debtor, as in having a conveyance set aside as fraud ulent, Schaller v. *178Wright, 70 Iowa, 668. The property, however, is in. custodia legis, and the assignee, an officer of the court, subject to its 1 supervision. Shoe Co. v. Mercer, 84 Iowa, 537. That the chose in action against the plaintiff for wrongfully suing out the writ of attachment passed to1 the assignee under the general assignment is not'questioned, and by section 3084 of the Code he is expressly authorized to “sue for and recover in his own name everything belonging or appertaining 1» said estate and generally do whatever the debtor might have done in the premises.” The very evident purpose of this section is to confer on the assignee the same rights and remedies relating to the estate as were possessed by the assignor. The remedy is on the attachment bond, and by section 3888 the defendant “may in his discretion sue thereon by way of counterclaim, and in such case shall recover damages as in the original action.” Is there any reason why the assignee should not be permitted to defend in the action instead of the assignor, who- was sued, or with him, and avail himself of the same remedies? He has precisely the same interest in the litigation. In Dunham v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.