U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Missouri June 26, 1899, No. 4,075 (Springfield Furnace Co. v. Miller Down-Draft Furnace Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-1899

ADAMS, District Judge.

This is a suit for an alleged infringement of letters patent of the United States No. 447,179, dated February 24, 1891, granted to Melville C. Hawley, for a new and useful improvement in furnaces. There are three claims in the patent, the first of which only is in controversy here. That reads as follows:

“In a combined downward and upward draft furnace, the combination of the lower upward-burning grate, an upper downward-burning grate, an intermediate combustion chamber and escape flue leading from said combustion chamber, the bars in said upper grate being spaced widely apart as described, and at each end thereof connecting with the water chamber, in turn connected with the boiler, ánd the bars in said lower grate being spaced closer together than are the bars of sáid upper grate, substantially as described.”

Claim 2 of the patent differs from claim 1 only in the addition of the element of having the bars in the upper grate spaced widely apart, and forming a series of zigzag spaces; in other words, the zigzag arrangement of the bars is the distinguishing difference between claim 2, which is not alleged to have been infringed in this case, and the first claim, which is alleged to have been infringed. The defendants have not employed the zigzag arrangement at all, and hence, if the first claim is limited to a zigzag arrangement of the bars of the upper grate, the defendants, not employing such arrangement, are dearly not guilty of infringement. It is contended that because the *419words “as described” appear immediately after tbe element respecting the bars in the upper grate being spaced widely apart in the first claim, and because! the drawings referred to show the zigzag arrangement, and the description of the patent deals with this zigzag arrangement, therefore the reference to the description and drawings in claim 1 necessarily makes the before-mentioned zigzag arrangement an element of that claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.