Court of Appeals of Maryland January 9, 1900 (Lewis v. Tapman)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1900

McSherry, C. J.,

delivered'the opinion of the Court.

This a suit to recover damages for a breach of promise to marry. That there was an agreement of some sort between the plaintiff and defendant to marry, is certain; but whether that agreement was absolute or conditional, is one of the grounds of contention. It is insisted by the plaintiff that the defendant agreed to marry her within three years from a designated date; whilst upon the other hand it is alleged by the defendant that his promise was conditional, and that in no event was the promise set up by the plaintiff to be fulfilled until the expiration of three years from the time it was made. We need not, though it would be quite entertaining if we did, refer to the evidence bearing on these controverted issues of fact, and we need not refer to it because the legal questions involved can be disposed of without quoting from the testimony. There is an inquiry

*296

suggested at the very threshold, and arising for the first time in Maryland, that may as well be considered and settled at once. Upon the assumption that the contract to marry was in fact made with a stipulation that it was not to be solemnized until after the expiration of three years, does it fall within that clause of the fourth section of the statute of frauds which prohibits any action from being brought upon an agreement not to be performed within a year, unless the agreement bp reduced to writing and be signed by the party to be charged therewith ? • This is the question which the rejected prayers, interposed by the defendant at the close of the case made by the plaintiff and set forth in the ninth bill of exceptions, presents.

A contract to marry was treated at common law, so Blackstone states,

Book

/, p. 433, “in no other light than as a civil contract;” but it is in reality something more.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.