New York Court of Appeals April 20, 1900 (People v. . Flaherty)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-04-1900
Parker, Ch. J.
By the judgment under review, Charles Flaherty was convicted of the crime of an act of sexual intercourse with a female not his wife while under the age of sixteen years. His contention in this court is that errors, greatly prejudicial to him, were committed in the progress of the trial, and the result of our investigation of the record has induced the conclusion that his contention is well founded. Some of the errors we shall now point out.
In the first place, the safeguards that the statute provides for The purpose of assuring a defendant in a criminal trial a fair and impartial'jury were not fully observed. While the law is not so unreasonable as to require the -exclusion from the jury box of all persons who have formed an opinion touching the guilt or innocence of the defendant on trial, it nevertheless treats the existence of such an opinion as establishing
prima facie
that the juror is disqualified, and the statute (Code Crim. Proc. § 376) then steps in and provides a method by which this
prima facie
disqualification may be overborne,
i. e.,
the juror must “ declare on oath, that he believes that such opinion or impression will not influence his verdict, and that
*13
he can render an impartial verdict according to the evidence, and the court is satisfied, that he does not entertain such a present opinion or impression as would influence his verdict.” But, as we have recently held in People v. Wilmarth, 156 N. Y. 566, if the juror, who is
prima facie
disqualified by his opinion, fails to make such a declaration as the statute pro-' vides, his acceptance as a juror by the trial court constitutes error of law, which may be reviewed in this court where, it appears that the defendant has been prejudiced thereby.
George H.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit