Supreme Court of Oklahoma June 30, 1900 (Mansur-Tebbetts Implement Co. v. Willet)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1900

Opinion of the court by

Buewell, J.:

This is an action commenced in the district court of Kay county by the Mansur-Tebbetts Implement Company, a corporation, against George R. Wil-let, for the sum of $88.40, as liquidated damages, on account of the defendant’s refusal, to receive, pursuant to a certain contract, nine buggies, which the plaintiff had sold to him. The defendant answered setting up a set-off for $119.35. To this answer the plaintiff filed a general denial. The case proceeded to trial and when the plaintiff rested, the defendant, by leave of court, dismissed without prejudice his claim for damages against the plaintiff, and demurred to plaintiff’s evidence. The demurrer was sustained, and judgment for costs awarded to the defendant; plaintiff excepted, filed his motion for a new trial, which was overruled, and then appealed to this court.

The petition is not framed upon the theory that the plaintiff suffered actual damages, nor were any actual damages proven. The suit is brought upon sec. 4 of the contract, which the defendant admits he broke, and plaintiff must either win or lose upon the provisions contained therein. This section is as follows:

“The purchaser agrees: Not to countermand this order; or any part of it, or have shipment held beyond present season, except on payment to Mansur-Tebbetts Carriage Mfg. Co., of 20 per cent of the invoice prices' of said order, as liquidated damages; and in the event we countermand said order, or prevent shipment as per this contract, we agree to pay said Mansur-Tebbetts Carriage Mfg. Co., said

*385

per cent as liquidated damages. If shipment of this order is directed held beyond time specified in this contract, it may be so held or cancelled at the option of said Mansur-Tebbetts Carriage Mfg. Co.”

The evidence shows that the Mansur-Tebbetts Carriage Mfg. Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.