Supreme Court of Rhode Island July 2, 1900 (State v. Foster)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-07-1900
Tillinghast, J.
The defendant, who has been convicted .of selling goods, wares, and merchandise as an “itinerant vender,” without first obtaining a license therefor as required by Gen. Laws R. I. cap. 163, as amended by Pub. Laws R. I. cap. 326, now petitions for a new trial on the ground that the verdict is against the evidence, and also on the ground of certain alleged erroneous rulings on the part of the trial court. He also claims that said statute is unconstitutional.
The material facts which appeared in evidence in the case, and which are not in dispute, are as follows:
(1)
The defendant is a merchant in the city of Providence, and has had a permanent place of business there for twenty-four years. He has also been a citizen of this State during all of said time. For several years past, at about Ohristmas-time he has temporarily opened a store at Woonsocket for the sale of his goods. In December, 1897, in pursuance of this custom,
*165
the defendant hired a store there for the exhibition and sale of his goods, and sold certain articles of merchandise as set out in the indictment, not having first obtained a State and local license to make such sales. After the testimony, which was very brief, was all in, the defendant, by his counsel, requested the court to direct a verdict in his favor upon the ground that the evidence did not show that he had violated the statute in question ; that, being a permanent resident and merchant of this State, he had a right to temporarily open a store in Woonsocket for the sale of his goods, and that such conduct did not constitute him an ‘ ‘ itinerant vender ” within the meaning of said statute; but the court refused so to rule, and instructed the jury that such a sale as that shown in evidence was in violation of the statute. To this ruling the defendant duly excepted. The defendant also claimed at the trial that the statute was unconstitutional.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit