Supreme Court of South Carolina August 2, 1900 (State v. Council)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-1900

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Pope.

The defendant was tried under an indictment containing two counts — one for burglary and the other for petit larceny. In the second count, he was charged with stealing six fowls, valued at $1.50, the property of

William T. Edens.

At the trial it was proved that the six fowls were the property of

Mrs. Annie J. Edens.

Under the direction of his Honor, Judge Benet, the jury rendered a verdict of not guilty. At another term of Court, an indictment was preferred charging the defendant with having been guilty of larceny in stealing six fowls, valued at $1.50, •the property of

Mrs. Annie J. Edens.

The defendant interposed in his defense a formal plea of former acquittal of this charge, which was not allowed by the Circuit Judge. On his trial, he was found guilty and sentenced. He now appeals to this Court.

The sole question raised is that it was the same crime of which he had been acquitted, that he was again put on trial for committing; and that such being the case, he was constitutionally free from such second trial. Of course, if it was the same offense on both trials, it was reversible error. But was it the same crime? In the case of

The State

v.

Copeland,

46 S. C., 13, this Court held that as the crime of arson was against possession rather than ownership of property, that property which was the subject of the charge of statutory arson, might have been alleged in the indictment in the name of the owner himself, or of the legal possessor of the property, on indictment alleged the property destroyed as that of the man in possession. The defendant was acquitted because the name of the owner did not appear in the indictment. Afterwards a new indictment was framed, charging the crime as against the owner, to which a plea of

*370

former acquittal was interposed. This Court sustained such plea. But in the case at bar, the true owner’s name must appear in the indictment to sustain an indictment for larceny.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.