Supreme Court of South Carolina September 17, 1900 (Shull v. Bradford)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-1900

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Chirr Justicr McIvrr.

For a proper understanding of the questions presentd by this appeal, it will be necessary to make a brief statement, derived from the record before us, of the several steps taken in this case, from its inception up to the time of the rendition of the decree from which this appeal was taken. It seems that the plaintiff originally brought an. action against Frances T. Caughman for the

*578

recovery of real estate — a lot in the town of Lexington— which resulted in a verdict for defendant. Thereupon the said plaintiff, as permitted by the statute, brought her second action against the same defendant for the recovery of the same real estate. After the issues in the second action were joined and before trial, the action abated by the death of the said Frances T. Caughman, on or about the 18th day of May, 1898. Thereupon the plaintiff, upon an affidavit stating that the said Frances T. Caughman had died, leaving a will, which had been duly admitted to probate, wherein one S. P. Wingard was duly appointed executor, but had declined to qualify as such, and that J. A. Muller diad applied for and obtained letters of administration, with the will annexed, upon the estate of said Frances T. Caughman,. applied for and obtained an order of Court substituting the said J. A. Muller as administrator as aforesaid, as a party defendant to the said action. The case then came on for trial before his Honor, Judge Ernest Gary, who upon the motion of counsel for defendant, sustained a demurrer to the complaint, granting leave, however, to the plaintiff “to amend the order of substitution, making the devisee under the last will and testament of Mrs. Frances T. Caughman, a party defendant, provided such amendment-be served upon defendant’s counsel within twenty days from -the rising of the Court.” This order bears date 5th October, 1898. On the 20th October, 1898, plaintiff’s attorneys served Mrs. Julia A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.