Court of Appeals of Texas April 26, 1900 (Missouri, Kansas & Texas Railway Co. v. Hanacik)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-04-1900

PLEASANTS, Associate Justice.

Appellee brought this suit to recover of appellant the value of a horse and a mule, alleged to have been killed by a train on appellant’s railway. The facts show that •appellant’s railroad runs through the farm of J. C. Brown in Fayette County, and, in compliance with the statute and for the accommodation of said Brown, the appellant had constructed a crossing over its railroad connecting the portions of said farm severed by said railroad, and had made openings by placing gates in the fence inclosing its right of way on each side of said right of way opposite said crossing. Appellee was a tenant of said Brown, but never used said gates, and same were not erected for his benefit. The animals in question were placed by appellee in an inclosure adjoining said farm, and escaping therefrom entered said farm, and through one of said gates, which had been negligently left open by some one, got on the track of appellant’s railway and were killed by one of its passing trains. Upon this statement of the facts this court certified to the Supreme Court the question whether or not the appellee would be entitled to recover the value of said animals without proof of negligence on the part of appellant, which was the proximate cause of the killing of said animals.

This question has been answered by the Supreme Court in the negative. Eailway v. Hanacik, 93 Texas, 446. The trial court in its charge to the jury, after properly instructing them as to the duty of the owner of said farm and his employes and tenants for whose benefit said gates were erected, to keep said gates closed, further instructed them as follows: “But if it be shown to your satisfaction that the plaintiff Anton Hanacik is a tenant of J. C.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.