Texas Supreme Court June 25, 1900, No. 881. (Nehring v. McMurrian)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-06-1900

WILLIAMS, Associate Justice.

The defendants in error, who were plaintiffs, brought this suit to recover an interest in the land sued for,- claiming such interest had been inherited from Peter Conrad, the original grantee, by his nephew, Frank Conrad, and that, upon the

*49

death of Frank Conrad unmarried and without issue, it had been inherited from him by his mother, Mary, and upon her death,'had been inherited by plaintiffs, her brother and sisters. There was no direct evidence of the death of either Frank Conrad or his mother, but plaintiffs undertook, by proof that they had both disappeared and had not been heard from for more than seven years, to raise the presumption (1) that Frank Conrad had died without issue before his mother, and (2) that the latter had subsequently died. Their evidence tended to show that Frank Conrad, then 14 to 16 years of age, was last heard from in 1868, since which time those of his relatives and friends who would most probably have received intelligence of him had not heard of his existence after due inquiry; and that his mother was last seen alive in 1878, since when nothing further had been heard of her. The verdict of the jury was in plaintiffs’ favor upon both propositions, and the sufficiency of the evidence to authorize the finding is not questioned.

The defendants adduced evidence of a witness which, if true, proved that Frank Conrad was seen alive as late as 1893, but this the jury must have found to be unworthy of credit. The assignments of error are based upon the refusal of a requested instruction and the exclusion of evidence by the trial court. The refused instruction was as follows: “The plaintiffs are not entitled to recover in this cause unless yon believe from the evidence that Frank Conrad is dead; and further, that at the time of his death he did not leave a surviving wife, child or children, or the descendants of either.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.