Court of Appeals of Texas October 13, 1900 (Lybrand v. Fuller)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-10-1900

ON MOTION FOR REHEARING.

COHHER, Chief Justice.

This was a suit, in the usual form of trespass to try title, in which appellant, by special plea, defended upon the ground that-the property involved was the homestead of himself and wife, praying for the cancellation of the conveyance under which appellee claimed as a cloud upon his title. The trial in the court below resulted in a judgment for appellee, and the case was submitted in this court upon the conclusions of fact and of law by the trial court, without a statement of facts. On the 9th day of June last we adopted the conclusions of law and fact and affirmed the judgment of the trial court upon the sole ground that appellant was estopped from claiming the benefit of the homestead character of the lots in controversy. Appellee’s

*297

title was by virtue of a.sheriff’s sale under a judgment and foreclosure of vendor’s lien upon certain notes given by one R. FT. Lybrand to the appellant for the purchase money of the lots in controversy. These notes had been transferred to appellee, after the maturity of the first note, to secure an indebtedness of $3000. The court found that the transfer from appellant and wife to R. FT. Lybrand was colorable merely. At the time of the transfer of the said notes to appellee, appellant represented and assured appellee that the sale to R. FT. Lybrand was actual, and that the lots in controversy did not constitute his homestead, appellant not having actual notice that such representations were false, as the conclusions tend to show.

While the question of estoppel was discussed at some length in appellant’s brief, our attention was not called to the fact that appellee, in his pleading below, made no reply to appellant’s special answer setting up the homestead character of the lots, and the invalidity of the title under which appellee claimed, and this condition of the pleading escaped us on the original examination.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.