Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 15, 1900 (People ex rel. Ray v. Henry)

Herrick, J.:

The relator contends that she has been removed from the office of general supervisor of the House of Refuge for Women at Hudson, N. Y., in violation of the civil service laws and the rules, and regulations of. the Civil Service, Commission, and for that reason seeks a reinstatement. .

In the view that I have taken of this case, it is of no copsequence whether the rules promulgated.