Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 1, 1900 (In re Munn)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1900

O’Brien, J.:

The petitioner moved to set aside and annul an assessment for $2,236.71 for a sewer as levied and confirmed on December 15,1897, against his premises at 31 and 33 Broadway, and for a reapportionment and reduction thereof on the ground that substantial error had been committed by the board of assessors. The petitioner’s affidavit states that the sewer was constructed along Morris street to Broadway, and thence north along Broadway to his northerly boundary line; that his premises have a frontage on Broadway of about 41 feet and an area of about 4,900 square feet, and his building is a. five-story structure; that the property adjoining his on the south has a frontage of 29 feet on Broadway, and a frontage of 184 feet on Morris street, an area of 9,400 square feet, and an office building-thereon of thirteen stories, the assessment, however, being only $971.78 ; that the property on the south side of Morris street, extending 248 feet along the new sewer, was assessed 'for $1,316.32; that the property on the east side of Broadway, opposite the petitioner’s property, was not assessed at all; that while the petitioner is informed and believes that some of the property owners assessed had notice of the proceedings to impose the assessment and appeared before the board with evidence, he received no notice and did not appear; that prior to the construction of the sewer the petitioner had the right of drainage across the property ad joining his on the south into the old sewer, but this drain was taken up, and the adjoining property thus became free from an incumbrance and gained as well the use of the new sewer, still being assessed less than he was. The total assessment was $4,524.81, of which the petitioner’s portion was $2,236.71, he being charged $53.78 per front foot, while the next highest charge was $6.33, and the lowest, $2.50.

The respondent contends that the issues here are to be determined.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.