Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 1, 1900 (Deuterman v. Gainsborg)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1900

Willard Bartlett, J.:

This complicated-controversy relates to the ownership of certain land under water, east of the middle line of a long mill pond or lake in Westchester county, variously known at different times in its history as Willets’ pond, Horton’s mill pond, Deuterman’s pond, St. Mary’s lake and Silver lake. This body of water, now about forty-seven acres in extent, has been formed by the action of an *576ancient dam placed' across a running stream which has thus been deepened and widened.

The present suit was begun by the late Charles Deuterman and has been continued by his executors.

The plaintiff claimed to own the whole of the lake and complained that the defendants had commenced to. drain- impure water and obnoxious matter into it, thereby injuring and polluting the pond and rendering the same unfit to procuré ice from. The prayer of the complaint was for an Injunction restraining such acts and for $5,000 damages; but the case was. tried solely as a suit for in june tion relief.

The answer did not question the plaintiff’s ownership of the lake west of the middle line, but alleged that the plaintiff was not the owner of the pond-or any land east of the center or original stream of the said lake, and that the defendant Gainsborg was the owner of the uplands on the east side of the pond and all the lands thereof under water to the center, or, more properly speaking, to the thread or middle line of the original stream. For an affirmative defense, the answer further alleged . that the plaintiff threatened to interfere with the defendant Gainsborg in the enjoyment of his own land; and the defendants prayed not only for a dismissal of the complaint, but that the defendant Gainsborg might have his boundary line, between the plaintiff’s lands and his own under the waters of the pond, fixed and established, and also his water rights and privileges in said pond.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.