New York Supreme Court January 15, 1900 (Tracy v. Dolan)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1900
Beekman, J.
This is an action for partition. The defendants answered, putting in issue material allegations of the complaint. As such issues are triable by jury as a matter of right (Code Civ. Pro., § 1544), an order was made by the court, on motion of plaintiffs’ attorneys, which, after reciting that it was insisted by counsel for the defendants “ that the issues should be tried upon the pleadings, without being stated separately, to which counsel for the plaintiffs agree,” directed that the said issues “ as made by the pleadings,” be tried by jury, and that for that purpose, the cause be placed upon the preferred calendar of the Trial Term for trial on the first Monday of Rovember thereafter, “ and that the verdict thereon when rendered be certified to the Special Term of this court for further proceedings.” The direction that the issues be tried upon the pleadings was a proper one, as the above-mentioned section of the Code authorizes the court either to direct the issues to be stated as prescribed in section 970, of to follow the course which was adopted here. The issues accordingly came on for trial, and certain questions having been submitted to the jury, the latter duly answered them, and the special verdict thus rendered was received and recorded. Thereafter the trial justice signed a paper containing findings of fact with respect to other issues than those which had been submitted to the jury, and also certain conclusions of law embodying his determination of the legal effect of the facts established by the verdict and his own findings. The verdict of the jury was rendered on October 13, 1899, and the findings above referred to were dated oh the same day. The attorneys for the defendants had no knowledge that the trial justice had been asked to make such findings, and their first intimation that he had signed any such paper was received as hereafter stated.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit