New York Supreme Court May 15, 1900 (Moon v. National Wall-Plaster Co. of America)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1900

Hiscook, J.

Defendant constructed a factory and put therein machinery for the purpose of calcining gypsum rock and manufacturing wall plaster. This plant was located in a not thickly populated part of the country district, not far from Syracuse. The machinery was extensive and more or less novel in its character. Operation with it was commenced about July ninth, and owing to some defects therein, from time to time large quantities of dust were' emitted and thrown upon plaintiff’s neighboring premises, causing him damages which were assessed upon the trial at eighty-three dollars and ninety-six cents. This condition and trouble continued down to the time when this action was commenced. Two days after its commencement (August 19, 1899) defendant shut down its plant for a period of about six weeks and endeavored to so remedy the defects in its machinery as to prevent the discharge of the obnoxious dust. For about ten days after it opened up the second time there was more or less difficulty of the same kind, but within that time defendant succeeded in so improving its machinery and the operation thereof as to substantially cure the difficulty, and from that time down to the trial of this action, in February, 1900, there had been practically no more trouble or ground for complaint, and there is no reason to apprehend that the trouble will recur.

While plaintiff’s complaint is broader than that, the only fault found with defendant upon the trial was over the emission of this dust

The first question is, whether the acts complained of as they occurred from the time the defendant commenced operations in July, down to August nineteenth, two days after this suit was started, constituted a nuisance. ' I think they did.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.