Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York April 15, 1900 (Ravin v. Subin)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1900

Per Curiam.

The defendant is a city marshal, and had in his hands a warrant of attachment issued against one Aaxonson, under which he made a levy upon certain goods, which, however, the plaintiff in this action claimed as his property. The defendant refused to recognize such claim, and* this action was thereupon brought to recover damages as for a conversion. Upon the trial the jury rendered a verdict in favor of the plaintiff for the sum of $175. An appeal was taken from the judgment entered thereon to the General Term of the City Court, where the judgment was affirmed, and from such judgment of affirmance an appeal has been taken to this court.

The only proof of value with respect to the goods that had in any way been given when the plaintiff rested is found in the testimony of the plaintiff himself, who, when asked what such value was, said “ I could not tell you exactly; I think it was worth about $275.” The record shows, however, that he was clearly not qualified as an expert to give any testimony whatsoever upon the subject. He states that before October 3, 1895, when the alleged conversion took place, he was a peddler of jewelry, and had not been in the grocery business before that time, but had had some experience in that line in Europe. Counsel for the defendant properly objected to this proof, and when it had been admitted *743over his objection, moved to strike it out. The defendant as a part of his case put on the witness-stand a person who was clearly-qualified to testify upon the question of value, who stated that the value of the property in question at the time of the levy was from $100 to $120, adding that it was the highest price. These two items of evidence constitute substantially all the proof that was offered upon the trial on this question.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.