New York Supreme Court December 15, 1900 (People ex rel. Marlborough Hotel Co. v. Feitner)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1900
Andrews, G. P., J.
This matter comes before the court upon a writ of certiorari and the return thereto to review an assessment for taxation in the year 1899, of property on the west side of Broadway, extending from Thirty-sixth to Thirty-seventh street, and known as the Hotel Marlborough. The assessment in question was at the sum *294of $1,185,000. The Marlborough Hotel Company, which holds the property upon a ground-rent lease which provides that it shall pay all taxes, presented an application in writing to the tax commissioners, within the time allowed by law, asking for a reduction of the assessment. The grounds of the objection, as stated in such application, were two: First. That the property was overvalued. Second. That the assessment was made at a higher proportionate valuation than other real estate on the tax-rolls. The tax commissioners considered the application, and reduced the assessment by ■the sum of $20,000, and confirmed it with that reduction. The company then obtained a writ of certiorari, and, the commissioners having made a return to such writ, the proceeding came on for hearing, and thereupon the counsel to the corporation moved to quash the writ, and the counsel for the relator moved for a reference to take testimony pursuant to the statute. The motion to quash was made on three grounds: First. That the writ was not applied for within the time prescribed by statute. Second. That the marketable value of the real estate was not stated in said application. Third. That a sufficient number of instances of overvaluation were not presented in the application. The first ground of objection was not urged, it being conceded that existing decisions of this court, as they now stand, determine this question in favor of the relator. The provision of law under which said application was made to the commissioners is as follows (L. 1897, ch.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit