New York Supreme Court December 15, 1900 (Freeman v. Brooks)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1900
Hiscock, J.
This action was brought by plaintiff as a taxpayer based upon the general ground of alleged wastefulness, to restrain the defendants from “ auditing, authorizing or allowing the payment ” of the sum of $13,761.95, or any portion of the same to Stone, Gannon & Petit, or to Charles L. Stone, as a balance for legal services claimed to have been rendered. The case was tried *451before a referee, and judgment has been had for the defendants, dismissing the complaint.
The necessary certificate of the referee, before whom the case was tried, is furnished upon this motion, and there is little dispute upon all of the facts appearing, but that the case has been sufficiently unusual and difficult to make an extra allowance of costs proper under ordinary circumstances. It is urged, however, in opposition to the motion that, in the first place, a taxpayer bringing an action of this kind should be treated with more consideration than an ordinary litigant, and, secondly, that the case is not one in which the Code permits an extra allowance of costs.
I agree fully with the contention made that taxpayer’s suits brought in good faith and upon proper justification should be treated by the courts with consideration in rulings which arc matters of discretion, and sound public policy dictates that the courts should always be readily accessible to- taxpayers seeking to protect their rights fro-m injury by the wastefulness, extravagance or corruption of public officials. When, however, a taxpayer has brought an action without due consideration, or which he is unable to support by necessary proofs, I am aware of no rule which exempts him from the ordinary incidents of defeat, such as the payment of costs. Gordon v. Strong, 15 App. Div. 519, 520.
The second contention made by plaintiff, above stated, that an extra allowance of costs in this case is not authorized, leads to a consideration of the language of the Code.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit